about
michael's website
Email Michael
 

Archives
January 2024
February 2022
September 2020
October 2017
November 2016
November 2015
April 2014
February 2014
August 2013
October 2012
August 2012
February 2012
October 2011
August 2011
July 2011
February 2011
January 2011
October 2010
Department of Transport manipulates road statistics

Every single year the Department of Transport announces road deaths are down.  Reporters attribute this to the Minister etc etc  In fact in 11 years the death toll has doubled annually in South Africa.  So is December a safer period or are the media being fed misleading figures?

This is my guess:

 

*year after year they change the reporting periods

*they announce and take credit for an early figure that does not include accidents not reported to them yet by various police stations and people who will still tragically die in hospital sometime after their accidents (which make the toll a bit higher by 30% on average)

*the next year they compare the real figure of the year before to the figures not including the above data and voila! – we once again have a reduction

*strangely enough the media releases from previous years invariably do not remain on the Department of Transport’s site

 

They have however not removed last year’s January press release yet:  http://www.transport.gov.za/communication_centre_sub.aspx?upd=1&comID=384&ssID=77

 

The media have reported that 1348 people died last year – but as this release shows, at the time they announced 937 deaths and that from 1 December to 5 January (a longer period than this year).  Now they announce 1050 this year and that they beat last year’s figure.  The stats are a laugh and when people are dying - and in increasing numbers - its not a laughing matter.

Posted by Michael de Broglio on Monday 04-Jan-10


Department of Transport manipulates road statistics

Comments

Juliet  said...
on Tuesday 12-Jan-10 10:37 AM
On return from an overseas trip I am once again shocked by how people/taxis drive in this country and the total disregard they have for pedestrians which seeps down from government not providing any pavements/cycle ways/pedestrian crossings/good public transport. In Europe if you approach a pedestrian crossing you stop, if you see a pedestrian 10m away from you you stop. Pedestrians are very well protected and EVERYBODY obeys the traffic rules and speed limits. Maybe that is because they have police that actually do enforce the law and the citizens actually do pay their fines.

Tony   said...
on Thursday 07-Jan-10 12:24 PM
Why would the death toll be in decrease if there are more cars on roads and people drive like lunatics these days , always rushing somewhere , always worked up about something .

Simon  said...
on Thursday 07-Jan-10 10:12 AM
"Statistics are like a bikini. What they reveal is suggestive, but what they conceal is vital." - Aaron Levenstein

g7f3  said...
on Thursday 07-Jan-10 08:30 AM
would be interesting to see stats published on the other months of the year to make an accurate comparison.

Ad  said...
on Wednesday 06-Jan-10 04:33 PM
on average a third of South Africa road deaths are the SAB Zombies - the "walking dead". The slowest thing on the road, speed generally is not the cause of death, neither is smsing while walking...

No amount of Road Blocks or visible policing has decreased this number, or ratio in comparison to the other road deaths...

As the largest single group killed on South Africa's roads - what is being done to address it?

or is it just too pedestrian to debate?

Safia   said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 04:56 PM
there must be much tougher system to fine and punish the offenders, something similar to the australian system . Also there is a complete disrespect to pedestrians in this country , watch how many foreigners will be dead during World cup . Taxis are human butcheries on wheels, the government is making too weak attempts to change the situation about it .

Allison  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 04:38 PM
I agree that decreasing the number of deaths on our roads is in our hands. The government only intervenes because there are people on the road that do not understand that their actions and decisions can take other road uses lives.

We should have visible speed traps! What does it help if the speeding driver gets the fine after killing somebody on the road?

Nicolle  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 04:08 PM
Government is attempting to present a united front. Because of course there aren’t any flaws in their system! Even if they were to recognise the error in their ways they would still proceed as they do now, by cutting corners and avoiding the bigger picture. I watched a documentary once and the whole issue was in regards to abuse in a government shelter (the abuse occurring mostly at night) and the Government official actually said “Do the people of South Africa really expect Government to get up in the middle of the night” That would just have to show the kind of mentality they operate on. If one is worried about travelling during the festive season they should take the necessary precautions themselves – not that you can account for the next persons stupidity – but if every person had the notion to be safe on the roads planted in their heads we wouldn’t need Metro hiding behind every bush.

Bianca  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 03:39 PM
I agree with the comments that the Government thinks that anyone that does not work for the Government or is associated somehow with the Government are complete idiots and also that they try and lead us to believe that they are working night and day to come up with solutions to the high death toll so that we will feel more comfortable driving, especially in December. At the end of the day you are the only person that cares whether you make it to your destination safely thus you need to drive safe and look out for the other people that have not value for their life.

Alexis  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 11:41 AM
What does it all matter, we are the ones who are in the wrong. Fine yes, the gov would like to look good and who doesn't. Honestly the difference between this year and last year is not really that much if you think about it.

We are the ones who need to bring that statistic down and are we, NO....here we are driving like we own the road ie SPEEDING, DRINKING AND DRIVING, MESSING ON OUR CELLPHONES WHILE DRIVING, NOT BEING MORE AWARE, RACING PAST EACH OTHER TO GET SOMEWHERE FASTER AND END UP BEING NEXT TO EACH OTHER AT THE ROBOT ANYWAYS and the list could go on forever and ever.

If you would like the gov to tell the truth, then imagine the public outcry saying that they are not helping with the problem, WHEN THEY ARE.....I have heard about more people being arrested last year for drinking and driving than I have before

We are to blame for this, WE need to be more responsible and stop messing around with our own lives, worst of all somebody elses!

Tonel  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 11:20 AM
Regarding us: following blindly like sheep,- everything in the Media should be dissected or at least be taken with a pinch of salt. We live in a time, where the Global Media is controlled in such a way that I think very little of what is out there can be taken as the truth, the world is full of half-truths, and it is everyone's interest/responsibility to not follow the media-country leaders -statistics etc blindly.

elaine  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 11:12 AM
this is nothing new, all goverments the world over lie to the general "public" about important information it's like the stats on aids,swine flu etc, if the genral public are stupid enough to believe the lies they put out in the media, we are in serious trouble! we all know this goverment is corrupt and its full of lying,corrupt officals anyway

Brenda  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 10:20 AM
This just goes to show that our government are doing absolutely nothing about the "safety" of the public on the road, and what for??... Because all they need is to keep their "names high", so the easy way to do it is to sabotage statistics so that the public think they are doing a good job. What HOGWASH.

Bridget Loock  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 10:18 AM
@Robyn, you're so right we are made out to look like stupid sheep with our heads down just following the heard. That's why we need articles like this.

Genevieve  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 10:17 AM
Maybe they hide this information from the public to make themselves look better. To make the public THINK that they have taken steps to cause a decrease in stats. They know that the public believe EVERYTHING that they read and won't do their own investigation. I think we trust our government TOO MUCH and people should take it into their own hands to be safer on the roads.

Bridget Loock  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 10:12 AM
Great article, I admire your brazenness it takes a certain type of person to stand out of the croud and give a strong voice to our unspoken concerns and expose the serwerage that runs beneath the illusions.

Julie  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 10:02 AM
True and just information to the public are withheld in many fields and aspects. For what reason? Why are crucial information not made public? Why "hide" important data we deserve to be informed about from us? Makes you doubtful about anything that is being published nowadays. Exactly WHO gains WHAT in the end?

david  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 09:59 AM
just goes to show - speed traps are not making people drive more safely. maybe the traffic cops need to climb out from behind the bushes, and attempt visible policing.

Robyn  said...
on Tuesday 05-Jan-10 09:59 AM
I totally agree. No laughing matter at all. I hate it that the 'leaders' of this country think that we are brainless and stupid. It angries me!!
All we can do is drive safely and cautiously. We must not be on our phones whether it's for an sms or a phone call. Drive sober.
If we don't do anything, no one will.

Post a Comment

* Your name:
* email:  (will not be published)
   Security Code:
*Security Code: Please type the above characters

 

Home




Johannesburg Web Design South Africa